Wednesday, July 17, 2024

Pepi pertinent to Palace G at Ebla

by Damien F. Mackey “Freedman himself even noted that the king named Birsha ruled not in Gomorrah but in Admah, contrary to what Genesis says …”. Matt McClellan Matt McClellan, in his article, “Abraham and the Chronology of Ancient Mesopotamia” https://answersresearchjournal.org/abraham-chronology-ancient-mesopotamia/ ambitiously - and, I think, unsuccessfully - grapples with issues pertaining to the right historical and stratigraphical location for Abraham; the ill-fated cities of Pentapolis; the Akkadian and Ur III dynasties; Hammurabi of Babylon; and Pepi ruler of Egypt. A focal point for his discussion will be Palace G at Ebla. Some of these issues, such as the location of Pentapolis, and the stratigraphy for Abram and the four coalitional invader kings of Genesis 14:1 - and hence for Pentapolis (14:2) - can be most satisfactorily settled, I believe, with reference to the penetrating research of Dr. John Osgood. Abraham, Moses and Hammurabi Matt McClellan, in his Abstract, will accept the old view that it was in Sumer “that Abraham had lived before he set out to the Promised Land”. And he refers here to another old view, that Abraham and Hammurabi were approximately contemporaneous: For many years, Abraham was believed to have lived at the same time as Hammurabi, king of Babylon. Later scholars would date Abraham to the period shortly before the reign of Hammurabi. However, the result of recent research is that the chronology of the ancient world is being redated. Hammurabi now appears to be a near contemporary of Moses instead of Abraham. All of this I consider to be wrong. Regarding Abram’s original home, for instance, see e.g. my article: Abram’s “Ur of the Chaldees” (11) Abram's "Ur of the Chaldees" | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu And, regarding King Hammurabi, he ruled centuries later than Moses, and, a fortiori, later than Abraham. On this, see e.g. my series: Hammurabi and Zimri-Lim as Contemporaries of Solomon (11) Hammurabi and Zimri-Lim as Contemporaries of Solomon | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu and: (11) Hammurabi and Zimri-Lim as Contemporaries of Solomon. Part Two: Zimri-lim's Mari Palace and King Solomon | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu and: (11) Hammurabi and Zimri-Lim as contemporaries of Solomon. Part Two (b): Zimri-Lim's Palace and the four rivers? | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu Dr. John Osgood, too, ceases to be helpful here with his mis-dating (my view) of Hammurabi to the time of Joshua. If Hammurabi were, as written above, “a near contemporary of Moses”, then it could be argued, as many have done, that the Mosaïc Torah was inspired by a pagan Babylonian Law Code. In a properly revised context (my view), King Hammurabi would instead have come under the influence of Mosaïc law filtered through, say, King David of Israel. Unfortunately, therefore, Matt McClellan will proceed ‘up a garden path’ in trying to establish what he calls “this new chronological revolution”: In Egyptian chronological studies, the patriarchs are dated earlier than ever before. In spite of this, there has been little research conducted on the relationship between Abraham and Mesopotamia in this new chronological revolution. This article will look at the current trends in chronological studies and how they relate to the life of Abraham. It will come to the conclusion that Abraham lived much earlier in Mesopotamian history than what most have realized. Matt McClellan will pursue a course that would set Abraham in the Ur III to Isin-Larsa period (c. 2112-1763 BC): Today the usual dating of Abraham in Mesopotamia is in either the Ur III or Isin-Larsa periods (see table 1). This depends upon the different interpretations concerning biblical chronology. …. Kenneth Kitchen, for instance, dates the oppression of the Israelites in Egypt from c. 1320–1260/1250 and the Exodus around 1260/1250 and uses a 645 year period between Abraham and the Exodus. This gives a date for the period between Abraham and Joseph from around 1900–1600 (Kitchen 2003, pp. 358–359). …. This would place Abraham during the Isin-Larsa period. There are other ways of dating Abraham including the use of the popular date of 1446 for the Exodus and 645 years between Abraham and the Exodus. Using this method one will date Abraham’s 75th year in the year 2091 during the Ur III period. It is during this period that Gleason Archer has placed Abraham (Archer 2007, p. 183). With 430 years between Abraham’s 75th year and the Exodus he would have arrived in Canaan in the year 1876 during the Isin-Larsa period like Kitchen dates him. Alfred Hoerth, in his Archaeology and the Old Testament, uses this method to date Abraham to this period (Hoerth 1998, pp. 58–59). The Ur III and Isin-Larsa period, needing to be re-dated and re-defined, is nowhere near the time of Abraham, or even that of Moses. Ur III again pertains to Hammurabi at the time of King Solomon of Israel, according to e.g. my article: Ur III and Hammurabi (14) Ur III and Hammurabi | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu The Middle Bronze Age, which coincides with Ur III, proves to be a disastrous choice for the archaeological era of Abraham. The Middle Bronze I (MBI) people are clearly the Exodus Israelites, a half a millennium after Abraham, who belongs to the Late Chalcolithic/Early Bronze era. This is where Dr. John Osgood’s research really comes to the fore and is a must read (EN Tech. J., vol. 2, 1986, pp. 56–76): https://creation.com/images/pdfs/tj/j02_1/j02_1_56-76.pdf The Times of the Judges — The Archaeology: (a) Exodus to Conquest See also my article Egal Israel accepts the MBI peoples as being the Israelites of the Exodus (3) Egal Israel accepts the MBI peoples as being the Israelites of the Exodus | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu For the correct archaeology of Abraham, finally, see Dr. Osgood’s groundbreaking article (EN Tech. J., vol. 2, 1986, pp. 77–87): https://creation.com/images/pdfs/tj/j02_1/j02_1_77-87.pdf The Times of Abraham Matt McClellan, by contrast, struggles with a lack of specificity regarding Abraham, Ur III, and the Archaeological Ages: Using Ussher’s date of 1491 for the Exodus and 645 years Abraham would have entered Canaan in the year 2136 during the reign of the Gutium. Using 430 years would place the same event in 1921 during the Isin-Larsa period. To make things even more complicated many scholars seem to date Abraham (and the other patriarchs) to the Middle Bronze Age without being specific on whether Abraham lived during Ur III or Isin-Larsa (Albright 1963, pp. 4, 7; Bright 1981, p. 83; LaSor, Hubbard and Bush 1996, pp. 41–43; Rooker 2003, pp. 233–235). …. Adding Ebla (Tell Mardikh) Thanks to the truth-depriving censorship of Ebla by the Syrian government: Bible-affirming Ebla hampered and censored by Syrian authorities (14) Bible-affirming Ebla hampered and censored by Syrian authorities | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu biblical scholars and historians have been dreadfully short-changed regarding the fascinating site of Ebla. Hence one is not entirely sure what to believe about it. Matt McClellan introduces the important Ebla as “A New Twist”: …. In 1974, the archaeological world was rocked with the discovery of the archives of the ancient city of Ebla in Syria. The archives of the city dated back to before the days of the Akkadian Empire …. These texts reveal that Ebla was a thriving commercial city with contacts stretching in all directions for hundreds of miles. The discovery affected not only Near Eastern studies but also biblical studies. Shortly after this discovery David Noel Freedman argued that the discovery of the archives gave evidence for placing the patriarchs into the period of Mesopotamian history before Sargon, the founder of the Akkadian Empire. This would have been the period which Kitchen said was too early for the patriarchs. David Noel Freedman was highly enthusiastic about Ebla, but he wrongly identified Pentapolis (and many have followed him in this) with Bab edh-Dhra and its environs, which Dr. John Osgood, however, with a properly set archaeology for the Israelites as the MBI people, has been able to show were Transjordanian (not Pentapolitan) sites conquered by the marauding Exodus Israelites. According to Matt McClellan: Freedman stated that one of the tablets listed the five Cities of the Plain in the same order in which they were listed in Genesis. It even named one of the five kings in almost the same form as Genesis (Birsha). This allowed Freedman to say that the patriarchs lived in the Early Bronze Age (EBA) which is traditionally dated to the third millennium BC (Freedman 1978, pp. 148, 154–155, 157–158). Freedman went on to argue that the Early Bronze Age remains just east of the Dead Sea were where the five cities were located. It was believed that Bab edh-Dhra and four other sites nearby were the Cities of the Plain. This was backed up by the fact that there were no Middle Bronze Age sites in the area but only Early Bronze Age sites. Interestingly the Early Bronze Age was the same period as the Ebla archive (Freedman 1978, p. 152). It is now accepted by most scholars that Freedman’s conclusions are false. The tablet does not list all five of the cities and concerning the name of Birsha, John Bimson notes that there are several examples of kings with the same name ruling centuries apart. So just because the name sounds like that of the king mentioned in Genesis 14 does not mean that it was him (Bimson 1980, pp. 66–67). Freedman himself even noted that the king named Birsha ruled not in Gomorrah but in Admah, contrary to what Genesis says (Freedman 1978, p. 155). Bimson also argues against Freedman’s archaeological evidence. He notes that Freedman’s argument depends on the fact that no Middle Bronze I sites have been discovered so that Freedman must assume that the Early Bronze Age sites are the Cities of the Plain. Bimson says: Unless the EBA settlements can be identified with certainty as the “cities of the plain” (which would require four of them being shown to have suffered a simultaneous fall in the EBA; Zoar was not destroyed according to [Genesis] 19), Freedman’s case remains weak (Bimson 1980, p. 67). Adding Egypt to Ebla Pepi I is to be considered here. I have identified Pepi I of the Sixth Dynasty (top right) all at once with Chephren/ Khafre of the Fourth Dynasty (top left); Pepi II of the Sixth Dynasty; and Sesostris I-III of the Twelfth Dynasty (bottom). On this, see e.g. my article: Moses, Egypt, Kings before the Exodus (5) Moses, Egypt, Kings before the Exodus | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu Matt McClellan continues, now telling at which of its stages Ebla synchronises with Pepi (so-called I) of Egypt, McClellan’s favoured era for Abraham: … The city of Ebla is located in present-day Syria. The city was discovered in the remains of Tell Mardikh. Among the findings discovered was the city’s archive located in the palace. Archaeologists have designated this palace as palace G. Interestingly palace G is dated to the Early Bronze Age. The archive includes more than 17,000 complete and fragmentary documents. Included are letters, administrative, economic, juridical, lexical, and literary texts which give us information concerning the city’s social, economic, and governmental structure, as well as the religion of the city (Archi 1997, pp. 184–185; Matthiae 1997, p. 181). The Ebla tablets were written during the reigns of the last three kings of Ebla and thus constitute a “living” archive (Archi 1997, p. 184; Astour 2002, p. 59; Matthiae 1997, p. 181). …. The Ebla archives allow us to connect Mesopotamian chronology with Egyptian chronology during this early period at one very specific point: the name of Pepi I (of the Sixth Dynasty) was found among the ruins of palace G (Archi 1997, p. 184; Astour 2002, p. 60; Gelb 1981, p. 58; Matthiae 1997, p. 181; Pettinato 1986, p. 58). The name of Pepi I (along with another Egyptian king—Khufu, the builder of the Great Pyramid during the Fourth Dynasty) was found in undisturbed layers of the debris of palace G which shows us that it was not placed there after the destruction of the palace archive (Astour 2002, p. 60). This all fits like a glove with my revision. Pepi I (Chephren) was the ruler of Egypt who followed the dynastic “new king” (Exodus 1:8). Moses was Mentuhotep/Weni, the Chief Vizier and Judge of Egypt at the time. His foster-mother was Ankhesenmerire, the wife of Pepi, the daughter of Khui (Khufu = Cheops). She (also Meresankh) was the “Merris” of Artapanus (“On Moses”), who married “Chenephres” (or Chephren = Pepi). Moses eventually fled from Pepi (as Sesostris), as according to the garbled Egyptian account of the adult Moses in The Story of Sinuhe. In the Book of Exodus we are told that Moses fled to the land of Midian (2:15). So, it is perfectly in accord with my revision that successive rulers of Egypt, Cheops and Pepi {“The name of Pepi I (along with another Egyptian king—Khufu …”)} - conventionally well separated, and of different dynasties - should be found together. And, indeed at the Early Bronze level {“Interestingly palace G is dated to the Early Bronze Age”}, which is the very level of Canaanite civilisation against which Moses, Joshua and the MBI Israelites would later march. An Abrahamic context this is not, so Matt McClellan is probing in the wrong place at the wrong time: The Sixth Dynasty is the latest that Abraham could have been in Egypt (McClellan 2011). Since Pepi I was a king during this dynasty and is dated to the period before the destruction of palace G, we can use the palace archives to date Abraham within Mesopotamia history. The question is to which period in Mesopotamian history does palace G correlate? There are different opinions, but Ebla is dated using thousands of texts discovered there to show that the palace was destroyed before or sometime during the Akkadian Empire. Nor would I be so quick as to dismiss Paolo Matthiae’s suggested identification of Sargon and Akkad at Ebla – though, if he is correct, this could not have any possible correlation with the much later era (about half a millennium after Sargon) of Moses: Sargon and his grandson, Naram-Sin, the first and fourth kings of Akkad, have been the two most cited kings who could have destroyed palace G. Both kings boast that they conquered Ebla (Bermant and Weitzman 1979, p. 172). Paolo Matthiae is one scholar who believes that palace G was destroyed by Naram-Sin. He notes that the name Shariginu in a text found at Ebla may be Sargon and that Akkad is mentioned as A-ga-duki EN (Matthiae 1977, pp. 166–167). These two names would mean that Sargon reigned during part of the Ebla dynasty before the destruction of palace G (Matthiae 1977, pp. 168–169). To support the theory of Naram-Sin as the conqueror, the pottery found at Ebla seemed to correspond to the period of Naram-Sin, suggesting that he was, in fact, the conqueror of Ebla and destroyer of palace G (Bermant and Weitzman 1979, p. 170). However, there are problems with this thesis. Bermant and Weitzman (1979, p. 172) note that the pottery once thought to belong to the period of Naram-Sin now is believed by some scholars to date to the period before Naram-Sin. Names originally translated as Sargon and Akkad were shown to be a nonentity called Shariginu and an unimportant town named Arugadu (Bermant and Weitzman 1979, p. 174). Perhaps yet further solutions may be attained by recognising: Sargon [as] Naram-Sin (4) Sargon and Naram-Sin | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu Matt McClellan will go on to refer to Michael Astour’s view that Sargon’s Akkad is not mentioned in the Ebla archive: “Besides these problems, there are others as well. Astour (2002, p. 64) notes that there is no mention at all of Akkad in the Ebla tablets”. Be that as it may, I have identified Akkad with Ugarit: My road to Akkad (4) My road to Akkad | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu and Ugarit is most certainly referred to at Ebla: “The first written evidence mentioning the city comes from the nearby city of Ebla, c. 1800 BC” (Wikipedia, “Ugarit”).

Sunday, July 14, 2024

Moses a Figure of Controversy

by Damien F. Mackey “Freud had argued that Akhenaton, the supposedly monotheistic Egyptian pharaoh, was the source of the religious principles that Moses taught to the people of Israel in the desert”. The Velikovsky Encyclopedia Moses the Lawgiver, so revered within the Judaeo-Christian tradition, appears to be a figure of enormous controversy amongst certain highly-respected scholars and writers. From at least the time of Sigmund Freud and his book, Moses and Monotheism (1939), Moses has been presented as an enlightened Egyptian: http://www.sigmundfreud.net/moses-and-monotheism.jsp Freud was quite interested in Jewish history. At his time, persecution and hatred for the Jewish people was quite common. Being a pioneer in the field of psychoanalysis, he set out to investigate the origins of the Jewish people. Among his most astonishing claims was that Moses was not [of] Jewish. For one, the name Moses is not of Jewish origin and can be traced back to ancient Egyptians. The book is an attempt to apply psychoanalysis to the field of history. An extension on his earlier works such as Totem and Taboo. In keeping with his suggestion about the primal father, Freud argues that a small band of individuals, which Moses led out of Egypt during a time of great civil war, conspired against him and eventually killed him. [End of quote] In more recent times, the concept of Moses-as-an-Egyptian has been taken up by Ahmed Osman in his book, Out of Egypt: The Roots of Christianity Revealed (Century, 1998). In Part I, Osman presumes to identify Moses with the Eighteenth Dynasty pharaoh, Akhnaton (Akhenaten). I wrote an entirely unsympathetic review of this bizarre distorting of history in my article: Osman’s ‘Osmosis’ of Moses. Part One: The Chosen People (6) Osman's 'Osmosis' of Moses. Part One: The Chosen People | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu Freud’s book on Moses had also been a catalyst for Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky’s revision of ancient biblico-history. Thus in The Velikovsky Encyclopedia, we read: In 1939, with the prospect of war looming, Velikovsky travelled with his family to New York, intending to spend a sabbatical year researching for his book Oedipus & Akhnaton (which, inspired by Freud's Moses and Monotheism, explored the possibility that Pharaoh Akhenaton was the legendary Oedipus). Freud had argued that Akhenaton, the supposedly monotheistic Egyptian pharaoh, was the source of the religious principles that Moses taught to the people of Israel in the desert. Freud's claim (and that of others before him) was based in part on the resemblance of Psalm 104 in the Bible to an Egyptian hymn discovered on the wall of the Tomb of Akhenaton's general, Ai, in Akhenaton's city of Akhetaten. To disprove Freud's claim as well as to prove the Exodus as such, Velikovsky sought evidence for the Exodus in Egyptian documents. One such document was the Ipuwer Papyrus which reports events similar to several of the Biblical plagues. Since conventional Egyptology dated the Ipuwer Papyrus much earlier than either the Biblical date for the Exodus (ca. 1500 – 1450 BCE) or the Exodus date accepted by many of those who accepted the conventional chronology of Egypt (ca. 1250 BCE), Velikovsky had to revise or correct the conventional chronology. [End of quote] Dr. Velikovsky had, for his part, his own idiosyncratic view of Moses, to which I referred in my: Distancing Oneself from Velikovsky https://www.academia.edu/3689825/Distancing_Oneself_from_Velikovsky with reference to Martin Sieff: Velikovsky was a Jewish nationalist, according to Martin Sieff in his most interesting paper, “Velikovsky and His Heroes” … and consequently his heroes seem to have been more the ‘baddies’ of the Bible (Saul, Ahab), [since these were the nationalistic types] rather than the ‘goodies’ (Moses, Isaiah). But whether or not Velikovsky believed in God, not to have done so would not disqualify him from being able to arrive at a right synchronism for the Eighteenth Egyptian Dynasty, which I believe he achieved. Sure, his original model was defective and needed modifications in various places. But the final result has been an impressive platform for the re-building of ancient history upon proper foundations. His critics, including Clarke, have not been able to come anywhere near it. [End of quote] A major obstacle to the progress of the Velikovsky-inspired revision was the academically entrenched - and, purportedly, astronomically-fixed - “Sothic” (Sirius star) theory of ancient Egyptian history as worked out by the Berlin School chronologist, Eduard Meyer. Thankfully, pioneer revisionists such as Drs. Velikovsky and D. Courville, followed by other bright minds, have been able to blow holes in this absurdly artificial scheme. On this, see also my article: The Fall of the Sothic Theory: Egyptian Chronology Revisited https://www.academia.edu/3665220/The_Fall_of_the_Sothic_Theory_Egyptian_Chronology_Revisited This Eduard Meyer was also the one who had denied the very existence and work of Moses. We read this information in the Preface to Martin Buber’s book, Moses (1946): IN the year 1906 Eduard Meyer, a well-known historian, ex¬pressed the view that Moses was not a historical personality. He further remarked: "After all, with the exception of those who accept tradition bag and baggage as historical truth, not one of those who treat him as a historical reality has hitherto been able to fill him with any kind of content whatever, to depict him as a concrete historical figure, or to produce anything which he could have created or which could be his historical work." [End of quote] Admittedly Moses - not a native Egyptian, but a Hebrew fully educated in Egyptian wisdom (Acts 7:20-22): “At that time Moses was born, and he was no ordinary child. For three months he was cared for by his family. When he was placed outside, Pharaoh’s daughter took him and brought him up as her own son. Moses was educated in all the wisdom of the Egyptians and was powerful in speech and action” - has been most difficult for historians to identify in the Egyptian records. Impossible for conventional historians, who will always be searching in the wrong historical period, underpinned by its archaeology, but also difficult for revisionists. My own hopeful attempt to identify Moses as a high official in ancient Egypt can be found in an article such as: Historical Moses may be Weni and Mentuhotep (6) Historical Moses may be Weni and Mentuhotep | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu Finally, regarding Eduard Meyer’s “… anything which [Moses] could have created or which could be his historical work”, see my set: Tracing the Hand of Moses in Genesis https://www.academia.edu/8175774/Tracing_the_Hand_of_Moses_in_Genesis Tracing the Hand of Moses in Genesis. Part Two (6) Tracing the Hand of Moses in Genesis. Part Two. | Damien Mackey - Academia.edu

Sunday, June 30, 2024

King Den, harvesting water for a parched, thirsty Egypt

by Damien F. Mackey But, just as I have argued that Moses actually needs to be assigned to more than the one Old Kingdom dynasty - {I have set him in, all at once, the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth dynasties} - so too, now, does it seem to me that Joseph-Imhotep of the Third Dynasty also requires in his portfolio the inclusion of the First Dynasty. Introduction Most recently, I have done for the biblical Joseph, what I had done previously for his compatriot, Moses, that is, I have found for Joseph a combined Old Kingdom and so-called 'Middle' Kingdom location in the history of ancient Egypt: Joseph like a sub-Pharaoh to Horus Netjerikhet Joseph, whom I have multi-identified, was basically Khasekhemwy-Imhotep, that is, Imhotep, the famed - and later deified - great Chancellor of Horus Netjerikhet of the Old Kingdom's Third Dynasty, who reigned during a seven-year Famine (Sehel Island Stela). In their 'Middle' Kingdom guises, the pair were the ruler, Mentuhotep Netjerkhedjet, and his Vizier, Bebi. But, just as I have argued that Moses actually needs to be assigned to more than the one Old Kingdom dynasty - {I have set him in, all at once, the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth dynasties} - so too, now, does it seem to me that Joseph-Imhotep of the Third Dynasty also requires in his portfolio the inclusion of the First Dynasty. I think that Dr. Donovan Courville may have synchronised, in part - in relation to a severe Famine - Egypt's First and Third dynasties (in The Exodus Problem and its Ramifications, 1971). What has led me towards embracing this further step is that there is a ruler in Egypt's First Dynasty who well meets my criteria for Joseph's Pharaoh. I refer to Horus Den (c. 3050 - 2995 BC, conventional dating), supposed fourth ruler of that dynasty. The Criteria In the above-mentioned article on Joseph, I had suggested the following: So, these are the main points for which I would be looking in Joseph's Pharaoh: - Youth, perhaps a prominent mother at first; - Egypt united, sometimes through warfare; - A long reign, certainly exceeding 18 years; - A powerful (sub-Pharaonic) Chancellor; - Celebration of a Heb Sed festival; - Centralisation of power greatly strengthening the king's hold on the land. Now I find some of these marvellously included in the make-up of Horus Den. To test this, let us follow through Nicolas Grimal's brief account of Horus Den in his book, A History of Ancient Egypt (Blackwell, 1994, pp. 52-53): The reign of Den (Udimu), the fourth king of the dynasty, appears to have been a glorious and prosperous one. He limited the power of the high court officials, which had previously been allowed to grow dangerously during Merneith's regency at the beginning of his reign. Immediately we have here a collusion with some major points above: a young king, with a prominent mother (Merneith); apparent long reign (N. Grimal will give this as (p. 53): "Den's reign is estimated to have lasted for about fifty years") that was glorious; with centralisation of power under the king himself. King Den's proposed alter egos, Horus Netjerikhet and Mentuhotep Netjerkhedjet, are assigned long reigns - no less than 40 years, and, at the other end, 50 plus (p. 157: "Mentuhotpe II died around 2010 BC, after a reign of fifty-one years ...".). N. Grimal continues with Den (Udimu): He pursued a vigorous foreign policy, rapidly turning his attention to the Near East with an 'Asiatic' campaign on the first yerar of his reign. He even brought back a harem of fcemale prisoners, an act which was to be copied later by Amenophis III, This military activity, along with an expedition into the Sinai to deal with Bedouin must have influenced his choice of 'Khasty' (meaning 'foreigner' or 'man of the desert') as his nsw-bity (King of Upper and Lower Egypt) name, which was changed to Usaphais in Manetho's Greek version. He was the first Egyptian king to add to his titulature this third name; the nsw-bity title was evidently intended to reflect his active internal policy, including the building of a fortress, celebration of religious ceremonies to the gods Atum and Apis, and a national census (if the Palermos Stone is to be believed). Den also seems to have purused a policy of conciliation with northern Egypt, which was expressed not only through the name of his wife, Merneith, but also by the creation of the post of 'chancellor of the king of lower Egypt'. The tomb of Hemaka a holder of this office, was discovered at Sakkara It contained a quantity of rich funerary furniture as well as a wooden table bearing the name of Djer whoich may have been record of Den's Sed festival (Horniung and Staehelin 1974: 17). The inscription on this tablet includes the earliest depiction of a mummy, perhaps that of Djer (Vandier 1952: 845-8). This is surprising in view of the fact that there is no other evidence for the practice of mummification until some time later. In the tomb bult by Den at Abydos a granite pavement was found, the first known example of stone-built architecture, which until then had been exclusively of mud brick. f, as I have set out in various articles, Moses had served in ancient Egypt as a Vizier and Chief Judge during the so-called Fourth and Twelfth dynasties, then it would be fitting if his Hebrew predecessor, Joseph, had served in ancient Egypt during the Third and Eleventh dynasties. Moses was a high official of Egypt at the apex of its great Pyramid-building age, the Fourth Dynasty. But the Fourth was the same as, so I have argued, the mighty Twelfth Dynasty, also a time of Pyramid and Sphinx building. The Hebrews were heavily involved in these gargantuan building projects. This was the Oppressor Dynasty of Israel (Exodus). It must also be merged with the Sixth Dynasty, whose founder, Teti, bears some striking similarites to the founder of the Twelfth Dynasty, Amenemhet, so-called I, he being the "new king who knew not Joseph" (Exodus 1:8). Moses was the Vizier and Chief Judge, Weni, successively serving Teti (Merenre) and Pepi, as he tells in Weni's famous Autobiography; and Moses was likewise the Vizier and Chief Judge, Menthuhotep, successively serving Amenemhet (= Teti) and the great sphinx-builder, Sesostris (= Pepi). Like many Old Kingdom architectural achievements, such as the Great Sphinx of Giza, these are also so-called 'Middle' Kingdom achievements. In other words, the enigmatic Sphinx of Giza was built in 'Middle' Kingdom times, which were actually Old Kingdom times. Joseph Joseph, whose death is estimated to have occured about 65 years before the birth of his compatriot Moses, belonged to, as has definitely been established by now, Egypt's Third Dynasty. Joseph was Imhotep, a Vizier and lector-priest of incredible and lasting fame, continuing centuries beyond his time. He was apparently the architect of Egypt's first pyramid, the wondrous Step Pyramid of Saqqara, a material icon - so I believe - of his father Jacob's dream-vision at Bethel of a Stairway to Heaven (Genesis 28:12). Massive enclosures, serving Egypt as granaries, and dams - most of relatively short duration, use-wise - were built at this time: e.g., Gisr el-Mudir, Shon Yusef, Shunet el-Zebib, etc. Incredible that Pharaoh Netjerikhet had allowed for - even insisted upon it - such a massive effort in infrastructure in prepartion for a seven-year Famine that Joseph-as-Imhotep had foretold! A late document (Ptolemaic), the famous Sehel Island Stela (or Famine Stela), tells of such a seven-year Famine and of Netjerikhet's dependence upon the sage advice of Imhotep. Now, it has been argued that, since there appear to be no actual contemporary references to Imhotep - the one at the base of Netjerikhet's statue being better interpreted as a title, not a name - then Imhotep must have been a later fabrication, perhaps even a Ramesside conspiracy to delete from memory the real Joseph. I hope that I recently may have solved the problem by identifiying Joseph-Imhotep as Khasekhemui Imhotep (Horus and Nebti names) - thought to be of Egypt's Second dynasty or Third dynasty - accredited with the building of the Shunet el-Zebib great enclosure. But this now opens the door for some other potentially relevant identifications. We probably need to run with the suggestion of some Egyptologists that Khasekhemui is the same as Khasekhem, before the unification of Egypt. Khasekhem can now also be the most obscure Sekhemkhet, associated with the unusual Buried Pyramid, situated right next to Netjerikhet's Step Pyramid. The name Imhotep has been written in a graffito there. Sekhemkhet also has the name of Djoser, making it likely that he (Joseph/ Imhotep), and not Netjerikhet, was the semi-legendary Djoser/Zoser. Meanwhile, Khasekhemui also has the alternative name of Bebi, a name that had been associated with the seven-year biblical Famine by Dr. Donovan Courville (The Exodus Problem and its Ramifications, 1971). And he (also Sekhemkhet) had the name elements, Anhk-ti, which might perhaps enable for a tie-up of Khasekemui again with Joseph through the highly powerful, quasi-pharaonic, Ankhtifi, of long-lasting Famine fame, whom I have already identified as Joseph. So much for the Third Dynasty, Pharaoh Netjerikhet and Imhotep (Khasekhemwy). Can any of this lead us also in to the Eleventh Dynasty? What about Bebi (Khasekhemui again)? Did not Pharaoh Mentuhotep so-called II have a Vizer named Bebi? Note on sub pharaohs: Ramses II 'the Great', ruling over the massive kingdom of Egypt and Ethiopia, would appoint as sub-Pharaoh his famous son, the intellectual Khaemwaset. In my revised chronology, this is the same situation as Shabaka (Ramses again) and Shebitku Khaemwaset (Khaemwaset again), which has caused much chronological mayhem for the conventional chronologists based upon the evidence of the Tang-i Var inscription, which has Shebitku located to a phase of the neo-Assyrian era (Sargon II's) where, supposedly, he ought not have been. Pharaoh of the Famine Clearly he was, as has now been established - and as attested by the Famine Stela of Sehel Island - Horus Netjerikhet of the Third Dynasty, wonderfully served by Imhotep/Joseph. The Famine preparation infrastructure throughout Egypt is there for all to behold and to study. But what about the king's so-called 'Middle' Kingdom alter ego, which I suspect that he must have had, based on Moses 's belonging to the both the Old Kingdom (Fourth and Sixth) and the 'Middle' Kingdom (Twelfth)? My research is leading in the direction that Horus Netjerikhet was also the prominent ruler, Mentuhotep so-called II, who had a Vizier called Bebi at the time of a severe Famine, the same Famine as that during which Ankhtifi was so effectively active. In the Eleventh Dynasty, but construed as during the time of an apparent successor of Mentuhotep II, namely IV of that name, there occurred the "seven empty years" of which the farmer, Heqanakht writes. This could only have been Joseph's Famine. As in the situation of Ankhtifi, people were cannibalising each other due to hunger. I suspect that the various names Mentuhotep will need to be streamlined as I have found to have been necessary the case of too many kings Amenemhet and Sesostris in the Twelfth Dynasty, and also the need to merge Thutmose III with IV, and Amenhotep II with III, in the Eighteenth Dynasty. Mentuhotep would take the name, Netjerikhet, which is much like that of our Third Dynasty Famine king. So I suggest a combined Third/Eleventh dynasty era in the Egypt for the biblical Famine, with Mentuhotep-Netjerikhet as the compliant ruler. Profile of the Famine Pharaoh I expect that, when Joseph aged 30 entered the service of the Pharaoh of Egypt (Genesis 41:46), the king was the younger man, only at the very beginning of his reign. From the Palermo Stone it may be deduced that it was in the king's Year 4 when the surveyor's, the Egyptian "rope-stretchers", began making preparations for the massive building program that was about to ensue. Fourteen years later, at the time when the terrible drought had subsided, in Year 18 (Sehel Stela), Egypt was free from the scourge. Joseph would thus have seemed like a Father to Pharaoh, as Genesis 45:8 in fact calls him. Jacob, when he came to Egypt during the Famine would twice bless the young Pharaoh (47:7, 10). Under such circumstances, it was traditional that the king's mother took a firm hand for a time. As apparent from the pharaonic titles, and Joseph's name of Khasekhemwy, Egypt was unified at this time, north and south. Some battles were needed to achieve this. There was great abundance, followed by a massive Famine during his reign. The king was a long-reigning one, who attained to a Heb Sed festival in which his Vizier was heavily involved. He greatly limitefd the power of his officials, centralizing power, and becoming very powerful. Obviously, the king was a great builder. So, these are the main points for which I would be looking in Joseph's Pharaoh: - Youth, perhaps a prominent mother at first; - Egypt united, sometimes through warfare; - A long reign, certainly exceeding 18 years; - A powerful (sub-Pharaonic) Chancellor; - Celebration of a Heb Sed festival; - Centralisation of power greatly strenghtening the king's hold on the land. Some of these are immediately apparent in, now Netjerikhet, now Mentuhotep.

Joseph like a sub-Pharaoh to King Horus Netjerikhet

by Damien F. Mackey 'You shall be in charge of my palace, and all my people are to submit to your orders. Only with the respect to the throne will I be greater than you'. Genesis 41:40 Introduction Moses If, as I have set out in various articles, Moses had served in ancient Egypt as a Vizier and Chief Judge during the so-called Fourth and Twelfth dynasties, then it would be fitting if his Hebrew predecessor, Joseph, had served in ancient Egypt during the Third and Eleventh dynasties. Moses was a high official of Egypt at the apex of its great Pyramid-building age, the Fourth Dynasty. But the Fourth was the same as, so I have argued, the mighty Twelfth Dynasty, also a time of Pyramid and Sphinx building. The Hebrews were heavily involved in these gargantuan building projects. This was the Oppressor Dynasty of Israel (Exodus). It must also be merged with the Sixth Dynasty, whose founder, Teti, bears some striking similarites to the founder of the Twelfth Dynasty, Amenemhet, so-called I, he being the "new king who knew not Joseph" (Exodus 1:8). Moses was the Vizier and Chief Judge, Weni, successively serving Teti (Merenre) and Pepi, as he tells in Weni's famous Autobiography; and Moses was likewise the Vizier and Chief Judge, Menthuhotep, successively serving Amenemhet (= Teti) and the great sphinx-builder, Sesostris (= Pepi). Like many Old Kingdom architectural achievements, such as the Great Sphinx of Giza, these are also so-called 'Middle' Kingdom achievements. In other words, the enigmatic Sphinx of Giza was built in 'Middle' Kingdom times, which were actually Old Kingdom times. Joseph Joseph, whose death is estimated to have occured about 65 years before the birth of his compatriot Moses, belonged to, as has definitely been established by now, Egypt's Third Dynasty. Joseph was Imhotep, a Vizier and lector-priest of incredible and lasting fame, continuing centuries beyond his time. He was apparently the architect of Egypt's first pyramid, the wondrous Step Pyramid of Saqqara, a material icon - so I believe - of his father Jacob's dream-vision at Bethel of a Stairway to Heaven (Genesis 28:12). Massive enclosures, serving Egypt as granaries, and dams - most of relatively short duration, use-wise - were built at this time: e.g., Gisr el-Mudir, Shon Yusef, Shunet el-Zebib, etc. Incredible that Pharaoh Netjerikhet had allowed for - even insisted upon it - such a massive effort in infrastructure in prepartion for a seven-year Famine that Joseph-as-Imhotep had foretold! A late document (Ptolemaic), the famous Sehel Island Stela (or Famine Stela), tells of such a seven-year Famine and of Netjerikhet's dependence upon the sage advice of Imhotep. Now, it has been argued that, since there appear to be no actual contemporary references to Imhotep - the one at the base of Netjerikhet's statue being better interpreted as a title, not a name - then Imhotep must have been a later fabrication, perhaps even a Ramesside conspiracy to delete from memory the real Joseph. I hope that I recently may have solved the problem by identifiying Joseph-Imhotep as Khasekhemui Imhotep (Horus and Nebti names) - thought to be of Egypt's Second dynasty or Third dynasty - accredited with the building of the Shunet el-Zebib great enclosure. But this now opens the door for some other potentially relevant identifications. We probably need to run with the suggestion of some Egyptologists that Khasekhemui is the same as Khasekhem, before the unification of Egypt. Khasekhem can now also be the most obscure Sekhemkhet, associated with the unusual Buried Pyramid, situated right next to Netjerikhet's Step Pyramid. The name Imhotep has been written in a graffito there. Sekhemkhet also has the name of Djoser, making it likely that he (Joseph/ Imhotep), and not Netjerikhet, was the semi-legendary Djoser/Zoser. Meanwhile, Khasekhemui also has the alternative name of Bebi, a name that had been associated with the seven-year biblical Famine by Dr. Donovan Courville (The Exodus Problem and its Ramifications, 1971). And he (also Sekhemkhet) had the name elements, Anhk-ti, which might perhaps enable for a tie-up of Khasekemui again with Joseph through the highly powerful, quasi-pharaonic, Ankhtifi, of long-lasting Famine fame, whom I have already identified as Joseph. So much for the Third Dynasty, Pharaoh Netjerikhet and Imhotep (Khasekhemwy). Can any of this lead us also in to the Eleventh Dynasty? What about Bebi (Khasekhemui again)? Did not Pharaoh Mentuhotep so-called II have a Vizer named Bebi? Note on sub pharaohs: Ramses II 'the Great', ruling over the massive kingdom of Egypt and Ethiopia, would appoint as sub-Pharaoh his famous son, the intellectual Khaemwaset. In my revised chronology, this is the same situation as Shabaka (Ramses again) and Shebitku Khaemwaset (Khaemwaset again), which has caused much chronological mayhem for the conventional chronologists based upon the evidence of the Tang-i Var inscription, which has Shebitku located to a phase of the neo-Assyrian era (Sargon II's) where, supposedly, he ought not have been. Pharaoh of the Famine Clearly he was, as has now been established - and as attested by the Famine Stela of Sehel Island - Horus Netjerikhet of the Third Dynasty, wonderfully served by Imhotep/Joseph. The Famine preparation infrastructure throughout Egypt is there for all to behold and to study. But what about the king's so-called 'Middle' Kingdom alter ego, which I suspect that he must have had, based on Moses 's belonging to the both the Old Kingdom (Fourth and Sixth) and the 'Middle' Kingdom (Twelfth)? My research is leading in the direction that Horus Netjerikhet was also the prominent ruler, Mentuhotep so-called II, who had a Vizier called Bebi at the time of a severe Famine, the same Famine as that during which Ankhtifi was so effectively active. In the Eleventh Dynasty, but construed as during the time of an apparent successor of Mentuhotep II, namely IV of that name, there occurred the "seven empty years" of which the farmer, Heqanakht writes. This could only have been Joseph's Famine. As in the situation of Ankhtifi, people were cannibalising each other due to hunger. I suspect that the various names Mentuhotep will need to be streamlined as I have found to have been necessary the case of too many kings Amenemhet and Sesostris in the Twelfth Dynasty, and also the need to merge Thutmose III with IV, and Amenhotep II with III, in the Eighteenth Dynasty. Mentuhotep would take the name, Netjerikhet, which is much like that of our Third Dynasty Famine king. So I suggest a combined Third/Eleventh dynasty era in the Egypt for the biblical Famine, with Mentuhotep-Netjerikhet as the compliant ruler. Profile of the Famine Pharaoh I expect that, when Joseph aged 30 entered the service of the Pharaoh of Egypt (Genesis 41:46), the king was the younger man, only at the very beginning of his reign. From the Palermo Stone it may be deduced that it was in the king's Year 4 when the surveyor's, the Egyptian "rope-stretchers", began making preparations for the massive building program that was about to ensue. Fourteen years later, at the time when the terrible drought had subsided, in Year 18 (Sehel Stela), Egypt was free from the scourge. Joseph would thus have seemed like a Father to Pharaoh, as Genesis 45:8 in fact calls him. Jacob, when he came to Egypt during the Famine would twice bless the young Pharaoh (47:7, 10). Under such circumstances, it was traditional that the king's mother took a firm hand for a time. As apparent from the pharaonic titles, and Joseph's name of Khasekhemwy, Egypt was unified at this time, north and south. Some battles were needed to achieve this. There was great abundance, followed by a massive Famine during his reign. The king was a long-reigning one, who attained to a Heb Sed festival in which his Vizier was heavily involved. He greatly limitefd the power of his officials, centralizing power, and becoming very powerful. Obviously, the king was a great builder. So, these are the main points for which I would be looking in Joseph's Pharaoh: - Youth, perhaps a prominent mother at first; - Egypt united, sometimes through warfare; - A long reign, certainly exceeding 18 years; - A powerful (sub-Pharaonic) Chancellor; - Celebration of a Heb Sed festival; - Centralisation of power greatly strenghtening the king's hold on the land. Some of these are immediately apparent in, now Netjerikhet, now Mentuhotep.

Joseph also as Den, 'he who brings water'

by Damien F. Mackey "But, just as I have argued that Moses actually needs to be assigned to more than the one Old Kingdom dynasty - {I have set him in, all at once, the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth dynasties} - so too, now, does it seem to me that Joseph-Imhotep of the Third Dynasty also requires in his portfolio an inclusion in the First Dynasty. Introduction Most recently, I have attempted to do for the biblical Joseph what I had done previously for his compatriot, Moses, that is, I have found for Joseph a combined Old Kingdom and so-called 'Middle' Kingdom location in the history of ancient Egypt. On this, see my article: Joseph like a sub-Pharaoh to King Horus Netjerikhet https://www.academia.edu/121302694/Joseph_like_a_sub_Pharaoh_to_King_Horus_Netjerikhet Joseph, whom I have multi-identified, was basically Khasekhemwy-Imhotep, that is, Imhotep, the famed - and later deified - Great Chancellor of Horus Netjerikhet of the Old Kingdom's Third Dynasty, who reigned during a seven-year Famine (Sehel Island Stela). In their 'Middle' Kingdom guises, the pair were the ruler, Mentuhotep Netjerihedjet, and his Vizier, Bebi. But, just as I have argued that Moses actually needs to be assigned to more than the one Old Kingdom dynasty - {I have set him in, all at once, the Fourth, Fifth and Sixth dynasties} - so too, now, does it seem to me that Joseph-Imhotep of the Third Dynasty also requires in his portfolio an inclusion in the First Dynasty. I seem to recall that Dr. Donovan Courville may even have synchronised, in part - in relation to a severe Famine during the time of the First Dynasty's Uenephes - Egypt's First and Third dynasties (in The Exodus Problem and its Ramifications, 1971). What has led me towards embracing this further stage of synchronisation is that there emerges a ruler in Egypt's First Dynasty who well meets my criteria for Joseph-Imhotep. I refer to Horus Den (c. 3050 - 2995 BC, conventional dating), supposed fourth ruler of that dynasty. The Criteria In the above-mentioned article on Joseph, I had suggested the following: So, these are the main points for which I would be looking in Joseph's Pharaoh: - Youth, perhaps a prominent mother at first; - Egypt united, sometimes perhaps through warfare; - A long reign, certainly exceeding 18 years; - A powerful (sub-Pharaonic) Chancellor; - Celebration of a Heb Sed festival; - Centralisation of power greatly strengthening the king's hold on the land. Some of these are immediately apparent in, now Netjerikhet, now Mentuhotep. [End of quote] Now I find some of these, too, marvellously included in the career of Horus Den. But, the more that I look at it, the more have I come to think that Den might actually have been Joseph-Imhotep himself, rather than Joseph's Pharaoh. Biography of Den Let us take a look at this by following through Nicolas Grimal's brief account of Horus Den in his book, A History of Ancient Egypt (Blackwell, 1994, pp. 52-53): The reign of Den (Udimu), the fourth king of the dynasty, appears to have been a glorious and prosperous one. He limited the power of the high court officials, which had previously been allowed to grow dangerously during Merneith's regency at the beginning of his reign. "... limited the power of the high court officials ...", is precisely what Joseph had done, shifting all power to Pharaoh and to the priests (Genesis 47:20-22). Queen Merneith, whose precise placement within the First Dynasty has been somewhat difficult, may have been the mother of Horus Djer who now firms for me as another alter ego for Horus Netjerikhet/Mentuhotep Netjerihedjet (both names having the Djer, tjer, element). I had suspected that the biblical Pharaoh had begun to rule at a young age, and therefore may have had a mother to assist him in that early phase of responsibility. N. Grimal continues with Den (Udimu): He pursued a vigorous foreign policy, rapidly turning his attention to the Near East with an 'Asiatic' campaign in the first year of his reign. He even brought back a harem of female prisoners, an act which was to be copied later by Amenophis III. This military activity, along with an expedition into the Sinai to deal with Bedouin must have influenced his choice of 'Khasty' (meaning 'foreigner' or 'man of the desert') as his nsw-bity (King of Upper and Lower Egypt) name, which was changed to Usaphais in Manetho's Greek version. As a second to Pharaoh, Joseph would have been expected to lead military campaigns for Egypt, just as Vizier Moses would later do for "Chenephres" (Chephren/Sesostris). His other names given here are most interesting: "'Khasty' ... meaning 'foreigner' or 'man of the desert' ...". Joseph was indeed a foreigner in Egypt; and 'Usaphais', not a bad Greek transliteration at all (Usaph-) of the Semitifc name Yusef (Joseph) – the Uenephes above. And his Horus name, Den (Dewen, Udimu) is thought to mean: "He who brings water". Who, more than Joseph, would harvest water for Egypt with his large dams and his still famous Bahr Yusef (“Joseph's Canal”) which flows to this day? N. Grimal continues with Den (Udimu): He was the first Egyptian king to add to his titulature this third name; the nsw-bity title was evidently intended to reflect his active internal policy, including the building of a fortress, celebration of religious ceremonies to the gods Atum and Apis, and a national census (if the Palermo Stone is to be believed). Joseph, as Khasekhemwy-Imhotep (or Imhotep), likewise used name and serekh innovations. Some of his architectural infrastructure has been misinterpreted, for example great enclosures to serve as granaries have been wrongly identified as fortresses (see "the building of a fortress" above) and temples. A "national census" might have been essential in a national crisis such as a seven-year Famine. Den also seems to have pursued a policy of conciliation with northern Egypt, which was expressed not only through the name of his wife, Merneith, but also by the creation of the post of 'chancellor of the King of Lower Egypt'. Den's "... policy of conciliation with northern Egypt" may well be reflected in what N. Grimal has written about the supposed "first ruler of the Second Dynasty: Hetepsekhemwy", who can only have been Khasekhemwy-Imhotep (p. 54): ... Hetepsekhemwy, "the Two Powers are at peace". The 'Two Powers' were clearly Horus and Seth, and this interpretation is confirmed by Hetepsekhemwy's nebty name: 'the Two Mistresses are at peace', which must be another allusion to the political opposition between north and south. This north-south confrontation was not necessarily an actual physical struggle - it more likely referred to the country's tendency to split into these two regions at any time of conflict. Joseph's wife was Asenath (Genesis 41:45), an Egyptian name that shares with Merneith (above) the Neith element. A name at this time, like Asenath (Asaneth), was Ahaneth, who, too, is difficult to pinpoint in a dynastic context. The name Ahaneth may simply be a variation of Merneith, the presumed wife of Den. The new "post of 'chancellor of the King of Lower Egypt'" may have been 'created' just for Joseph. It was held by one Hemaka, as we will now learn, a powerful high official of Djer, a king of whom I wrote above: "Horus Djer who now firms for me as another alter ego for Netjerikhet-Mentuhotep Netjerihedjet (both names having the Djer, tjer, element)". The tomb of Hemaka a holder of this office, was discovered at Sakkara. It contained a quantity of rich funerary furniture as well as a wooden table bearing the name of Djer which may have been a record of Den's Sed festival (Hornung and Staehelin 1974:17). Once again, as with Horus Netjerikhet and Imhotep, Saqqara ("Sakkara") takes centre stage. Den may here have been recording Horus Djer's Sed festival rather than his own. Similarly, Mentuhotep's quasi-pharaonic vizier, Kheti, will be prominent in the case of his Pharaoh's Sed festival, presumably as its organiser: https://aminoapps.com/c/kemeticism-amino/page/blog/the-heb-sed-renewal-and-reaffirmation/J8lp_Bm1sduPveLjxknMoM71anWmar6NQ14 “… in the reign of Mentuhotep II (of the 11th dynasty), His “treasurer”, Kheti, who was involved in organising the Sed festival”. So far, I have not even come to this Kheti, whose name may be a hypocoristicon of Sekhem-khet (= Zoser/Imhotep). In Djer/Hemaka; Djer/Den; and Mentuhotep/Kheti, we have, I believe, three variant combinations of the one King and Chancellor. And we have not even included here Netjerikhet/Imhotep.

Biblical King of the seven-year Famine

by Damien F. Mackey The Pharaoh whom I am hoping to establish here will certainly be, like Moses' s first two Egyptian rulers were, a king of various names, dynasties, and even kingdoms, conventionally speaking. In reality, of course, he belonged to only the one dynasty, and only the one kingdom, of Egypt. Introduction Moses Egypt's Twelfth Dynasty ('Middle' Kingdom) encompassed the entire early life of Moses, from his birth to his recall to Egypt from his exile in Midian (Exodus 2:1-4:31). This was that mighty dynasty that oppressed, as slaves, the growing number of Israelites in Egypt. The first Oppressor King, the "new king who knew not Joseph" (Exodus 1:8), was Amenemhet (Amenemes) so-called I, "... the first ruler of a new dynasty. This is confirmed by his choice of Horus name: Weḥem-meswt ('He who repeats births'), which suggests that he was the first of a new line" (Nicolas Grimal, A History of Ancient Egypt, Blackwell, 1994, p. 158). This king would express his alarm at the growing number of "Asiatics" (includes Israelites) in the Delta region. He will consequently embark upon a massive building and infrastructural program, pyramids, temples, canals, agriculture, under whose weight the Israelites and other foreigners would groan. But this was also the famous Pyramid-building and sphinxes-raising phase (including Giza) of ancient Egypt. The early career of Moses enables for the beginnings of a comprehensive reconstruction of ancient Egyptian history, with the Fourth, Fifth (probably), Sixth, and the Twelfth dynasties now all to be recognised as being the one and the same. Basically, this era consisted of only the two major oppressor pharaohs, namely: 1. Khufu/Teti-Merenre/Amenemhet; and 2. Chephren-"Chenephres"/Pepi/Sesostris) Then briefly came a woman Pharaoh, Sebekneferure (likely at about the time of the Burning Bush incident of Exodus 3), followed by the Thirteenth Dynasty, with its Pharaoh of the Exodus, Neferhotep, and Israel's departure from Egypt. The career of Moses thus enables for a synchronisation (or tucking up) of Egypt's Old and 'Middle' kingdoms, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Twelfth and Thirteenth (partly) - all within a span of some 80 years - the age of Moses when in confrontation with the hard-hearted Pharaoh of the Exodus (7:7). Joseph Will the same sort of chronological service - but towards the reconstruction of an earlier phase of ancient Egyptian history - be provided by the life of Joseph? The answer to this will be: Yes. Abram (Abraham) Thanks to Dr. John Osgood ("The Times of Abraham", Creation.com), one can now tie up in the life of Abram (Abraham) various archaeological strata: namely, Late Chalcolithic (En-geddi); Neolithic (Jericho); Ghassul IV (Syro-Palestine); a near contemporaneous Narmer level at Arad's Stratum IV; Gerzean in Egypt. And all of this dovetailing at the time of the four-king coalition led by Chedorlaomer of Elam (Genesis 14:1-16), when five kings ruled Pentapolis (14:2: Bera, Birsha, Shinab, Shemeber, and the king of Zoar). A greatly aged Melchizedek (Shem) was yet then still alive as well (14:18-20). Noah And, similarly, I have wondered if Noah and the Flood may even hold the key to a more satisfactory lay-out of those highly-inflated Geological Ages - just as the life of Abram has served to demonstrate that the Stone Ages were not entirely linear, but were partly contemporaneous, and shrinkable. I suspect that, for one, the Eocene Sea (a mere 56-34 million years ago - you're kidding, aren't you?) was actually contemporaneous with the great Noachic Flood (c. 2900 BC), as was the Black Sea flood (c. 7000-5500 BC, conventional dating). The Bible defeats the linear evolutionary and Sothic (dynastic) models at every turn. Biblical King of Jacob and Joseph Old Kingdom (1) I include Jacob here because he, during the Famine, twice blessed the Pharaoh (Genesis 47:7, 10), who, I suspect, may have been quite young. The Pharaoh whom I am hoping to establish here will certainly be, like Moses' s first two Egyptian rulers were, a king of various names, dynasties, and even kingdoms, conventionally speaking. In reality, of course, he belonged to only the one dynasty, and only the one kingdom, of Egypt. To begin with, he is assuredly the notable Horus Netjerikhet, who oversaw the building of the famous Step Pyramid at Saqqara, and who is the king named in the seven-year Famine Stela of Sehel Island. The period is called Egypt's Third Dynasty (Old Kingdom). Netjerikhet's Joseph was Imhotep, also named in the Sehel Stela. But Imhotep needs to be filled out with alter egos, most necessarily with that of Khasekhemwy-Imhotep. Joseph-Imhotep must therefore have been a veritable sub-Pharaoh. King Horus Netjerikhet is often also called Djoser (or Zoser), but this, I believe, is incorrect. Djoser was another name of Sekhemkhet's, whom, too, I have identified with Khasekhem(wy), or Imhotep. In other words, Djoser was Imhotep. There is much proof for Horus Netjerikhet as the Famine Pharaoh, including the (admittedly late) Famine Stela, and the enormous dams, canals, and super granaries constructed at the time (e.g., Bahr Yusef, Shon Yusef, Gisr el-Mudir, etc.). This is undoubtedly one of the most incredible moments in all of history. Here was the ruler of a great nation bending to the advice of his foreign subordinate based on the latter's ability to interpret dreams, and thus ordering, or allowing for, the raising of a massive water-harvesting infrastructural program some seven years before the fore-warned crisis had even occurred. Conclusion One The Famine Pharaoh was Horus Netjerikhet. His Joseph was Imhotep (Khasekhemwy). ---------------------------- Before considering this king's other Old Kingdom guises - for he, like Moses's two early rulers must surely have had such - let us make a shift to consider his so-called 'Middle' Kingdom guise. Here we encounter another famous name. 'Middle' Kingdom Here we meet the mighty Mentuhotep II Netjerihedjet, also a famine Pharaoh. As Nicolas Grimal explains the situation (op. cit., p. 155. My emphasis): Mentuhotpe [Mentuhotep] II ... came to the Theban throne under the name S'ankhibtawy ... his domain stretched from the First Cataract to the tenth nome of Upper Egypt; in other words, it was still curtailed to the north by the territory of the princes of Asyut. A hostile peace was maintained between the two kingdoms, but this was disrupted when the Thinite nome, suffering grievously from famine, revolted against the Herakleopolitan clan. Mentuhotpe captured Asyut and passed through the fifteenth nome without encountering resistance - this was effectively the fall of the Herakleapolitan dynasty. A 'grievous famine' in Egypt was hardly likely to have been restricted to just the one nome, however. Nicolas Grimal will give more information for famine during the Eleventh Dynasty, though presumably after the passing of Mentuhotep II: P. 158: ... Mentuhotpe III .... Hekanakht also described the problems of his time, including the onset of famine in the Theban region. .... After the death of Mentuhotpe III ... the country was evidently left in a confused state. At this point the Turin Canon mentions 'seven empty years' which correspond to the reign of Mentuhotpe IV, whose coronation name, Nebtawyre ("Ra is the lord of the Two Lands") perhaps represents a return to the values of the Old Kingdom. Except that, this was the Old Kingdom! I suspect that Egyptologists have either turned the one great Mentuhotep (II) into an unnecessary succession (III, IV) - just as they have done to a greater or lesser degree with Pepi and Amenemhet and Sesostris and Thutmose and Amenhotep - or, that later kings Mentuhotep (or their officials) were reflecting back to Egypt's time of great Famine. The Famine - like Noah's Flood, like the life of Abram, and like the life of Moses - brings a much-needed cohesion to ancient geology (Geological Ages)/geography/ Stone Ages/archaeology/kingdoms-dynasties and rulers. Creationist Patrick Clarke, too (in his article, "Joseph's Zaphenath Paaneah - a chronological key", at Academia.edu), has pointed to the Eleventh Dynasty as being the most likely period for Joseph's Famine, with Mentuhotep II being the biblical Pharaoh. Unsatisfyingly, though, the author does not offer any suggestion as to who Joseph himself may have been in this Eleventh Dynasty context. Mentuhotep's Joseph was his Vizier, Bebi - {another name of Khasekhemwy-Imhotep} - who likewise lived during a protracted Famine in Egypt. Like Horus Netjerikhet, "[Mentuhotep] was a prolific builder [Heqaib and Satis at Elephantine; Deir el-Ballas; Dendera; Elkab; Gebelein; Abydos; Deir el-Bahri] ... he built himself a funerary monument modelled on the pyramid complexes of the Old Kingdom" (Grimal, N., op. cit., p. 156-157). But, as I must repeat from above: This was the Old Kingdom! Hence it is not surprising to read further (p. 157): "[Mentuhotep] also revived [sic] the foreign policy of the Old Kingdom by leading an expedition to the west against the Tjemehu and Tjehenu Libyans and into the Sinai peninsula against the Mentjiu nomads". Another potential anomaly. Raneb (Nebra), supposedly of the Second Dynasty, is generally consdered to have been the first ruler to have included the sun god Ra in his name. However, there is to be considered the possibility that this long-reigning Pharaoh (some 39 years?) was contemporaneous with - and I suspect the same as - Mentuhotep II, one of whose names, Nebhepetre (ibid., p. 155), contained both elements of the name Raneb (Neb and re). Conclusion Two The Famine Pharaoh was also Mentuhotep II Netjerihedjet. His Joseph was Bebi. ---------------------------- Old Kingdom (2) We are now going to look at Djer (Nynetjer?) and Djet. Djer Could this name, Djer - or Nynetjer? - have been a hypocoristicon (ne-)tjer element taken from Netjerikhet and/or Netjerihedjet (Mentuhotep)? The little known Horus It(i) Djer will do what we have just read that Mentuhotep did, that is, expand into Libya and the Sinai. Hence Nicolas Grimal (ibid., p. 51): "The reign of Djer was characterised by further developments in foreign policy, including expeditions into Nubia (as far as Wadi Halfa), Libya and the Sinai ...". Again, as with Horus Netjerikhet/Mentuhotep, Djer's reign was an opulent one: "Judging from the funerary furniture in the private tombs of his contemporaries, the reign of Djer was a time of great prosperity". Nynetjer Nynetjer, the supposed son of Raneb (above), is variously said to have reigned for 47 years (Manetho), or even the hardly credible 96 years. What we are finding in common with our potential Famine Pharaoh alter egos is a lengthy, prosperous reign of anything upwards of some 40 years. His reign experienced a phase of "poor harvests" (Ancient Egypt Online, "Nynetjer"): The end of his reign seems to have been marked by poor harvests, internal tension, and possibly even civil war. The Palermo Stone records fighting in several towns including one named "the House of the North". This reference may suggest that the king had to suppress a rebellion in Lower Egypt. A period of Famine is another common denominator, as is conquest of the North, and an active foreign policy. Djet And could this name, Djet, have been a hypocoristicon djet element taken from Netjerihedjet (Mentuhotep)? Unfortunately, we meet again that regular phrase, "little is known about". Thus Nicolas Grimal (op. cit., p. 52): Very little is known about Djer's successor, Djet or Wadjit (or 'Serpent' if his name is taken as a pure pictogram), except that he led an expedition to the Red Sea, perhaps with the aim of exploring the mines in the Eastern Desert. Djet's tomb at Abydos contained numerous stelae, including a magnificent limestone example inscribed with his name (Paris, Louvre). Not much to be derived from Grimal here on either Djer, Nynetjer or Djet. But another source tells us that Egypt suffered a major famine during the reign of Djet, and that, I would suggest, ties him to Netjerihedjet (Mentuhotep). Another of Djet's names was Uenephes of Famine consideration. Manetho said that a great famine occurred during this reign. Djer, Nynetjer or Djet's Joseph was his powerful sub-Pharaoh, Den (Udimu), whose names tell it all. Den means "He who brings water'. Consider the vast water harvesting projects undertaken at the time. His name 'Khasty' means 'foreigner', most apropriate for Joseph, a Hebrew living in Egypt. And Manetho's name for him, Usaphais, tells us clearly that he is Joseph (Yosef, Yusef), Usaiph- = Yusef. Conclusion Three The Famine Pharaoh was also Djer, Nynetjer or Djet. His Joseph was Den (Udimu) Usaphais. ---------------------------- A further commonality: The Sed festival was celebrated by Netjerikhet, by Mentuhotep Netjerihedjet, and one is also attributed to Den, but ought likely be attributed to his Pharaoh instead. In these cases, the ruler's second-in-charge official is notably conspicuous - no doubt organising the festival for the Pharaoh.

Sunday, June 23, 2024

Joseph, whose coat was of many colours, was a man of many names

by Damien F. Mackey And, perhaps most telling of all, Manetho's Usaphais, a virtually perfect Greek transliteration of the Semitic name, Yusef (=Usaph-), or Joseph. Apparently in the search for the historical Joseph, as was the case with Moses, one will need to - in order to find him in all of his fulness - course through various of the old Egyptian dynasties, both Old Kingdom and so-called 'Middle' Kingdom. This is what I have come up with so far: Basically, Joseph was - as many are now thinking (see Internet and You Tube) - Imhotep of Egypt's Third Dynasty, who brilliantly served Horus Netjerikhet. But Imhotep, simply qua Imhotep, does not appear to be very well attested from contemporaneous records, so much so that some say he may never have existed, but may have been a later (say, Ramesside, or Ptolemaïc) fabrication. That problem can be nicely solved, I think, by recognising Imhotep as the Second Dynasty, or the Third Dynasty character, Khasekhemwy-Imhotep (variously Hetep-Khasekhemwy, Khasekhem, or Sekhemkhet). Of this Khasekhemwy, we read (Britannica) that "... he was the first to use extensive stone masonry". But, then, something similar is said again of Horus Den (Dewen, Udimu) of the First Dynasty. Thus, Nicolas Grimal (A History of Ancient Egypt, Blackwell, p. 53. My emphasis): "In the tomb built by Den at Abydos a granite pavement was found, the first known example of stone-built architecture, which until then had been exclusively of mud brick". And it is said, again, of Netjerikhet (ibid., p. 64): "... Netjerykhet ... is famed for having invented stone-built architecture with the help of his architect Imhotep ...". Very confusing! "... Den ... first known example of stone-built architecture ...". Khasekhemwy "... first to use extensive stone masonry". "... stone-built architecture [invented] with the help of ... Imhotep ...". Never mind, if - as I am proposing - Den, was Khasekhemwy, was Imhotep. Now, Den supposedly had a powerful Chancellor, Hemaka, who might likewise be considered as a potential candidate for Joseph (Wikipedia, article "Hemaka". My emphasis): One of Hemaka's titles was that of "seal-bearer of the King of Lower Egypt" ... effectively identifying him as chancellor and second in power only to the king. .... The tomb of Hemaka is larger than the king's own tomb, and for years was mistakenly thought as belonging to Den. But not a mistake if Hemaka was Den! And Den's wife, Merneith, may be the same as Ahaneth, a name almost identical to that of Joseph's wife, Aseneth (Asenath/Ahaneth) (Cf. Genesis 41:45, 50; 46:20). This Ahaneth must have been very important considering the large size of her tomb. Den's ruler may have been Horus Djer, which name recalls Horus Netjerikhet. Joseph's given Egyptian name, Zaphenath paneah, which biblical commentators generally find so difficult to interpret, I have connected in some of its elements, as a hypocoristicon, with Ankhtifi, a quasi-pharaonic like official (of no definitely fixed address) whose records boast of him as being 'unlike any man ever born', and who fails even to make any clear reference to his ruler. Ankhtifi, and the prolonged Famine of his time, with people cannibalising one another, I have linked to other similarly-described famines, of Bebi, and also the one at the time of Heqanakht. And I have then tentatively suggested a connection between the Famine personage, Bebi, and the Vizier of that same name serving Mentuhotep, so-called II, of the Eleventh Dynasty ('Middle' Kingdom). This powerful king, Mentuhotep, also had a Chancellor of Ankhtifi-like prominence and importance, Kheti. Previously I wrote on King and Chancellor pairings: Once again, as with Horus Netjerikhet and Imhotep, Saqqara ("Sakkara") takes centre stage. Den may here have been recording Horus Djer's Sed festival rather than his own. Similarly, Mentuhotep's quasi-pharaonic vizier, Kheti, will be prominent in the case of his Pharaoh's Sed festival, presumably as its organiser. So far, I have not even come to this Kheti, whose name may be a hypocoristicon of Sekhem-khet (= Zoser/Imhotep). In Djer/Hemaka; Djer/Den; and Mentuhotep/Kheti, we have, I believe, three variant combinations of the one King and Chancellor. And we have not even included here Netjerikhet/Imhotep. The multi-named Joseph From what we have just read, Joseph's names may include Imhotep; Khasekhemwy-Imhotep; Hetep-Khasekhemwy; Khasekhem; Sekhemkhet; Den (Dewen, Udimu); Khasti; Uenephes; Usaphais (Yusef); Zaphenath paneah; Ankhtifi; Bebi and perhaps also: Hemaka; Kheti From stark obscurity, the historical Joseph now abounds! And I suspect that this will not exhaust the potential list of Egyptian (also including some Greek) names for the biblical Joseph.